Chapter 2 - The Red Ribbon Key
The neon glow of the phone screen illuminated the dark master bedroom like an alarm pulse. My heart didn't just race; it slammed against my ribs with the force of a trapped bird.
"David!" I screamed, my voice shredding in my throat. "David, she's in his room!"
My husband exploded out of sleep, his boots hitting the hardwood floor before his eyes were fully open. We sprinted down the narrow hallway of our new colonial home in Greenwich, Connecticut—a home we had bought precisely because the real estate agent assured us it was in the safest cul-de-sac in the county.
I reached Sam’s nursery door first and threw my body against it.
It was locked from the inside.
"Sam! Sam!" I battered the heavy oak paneling with my fists, the skin splitting over my knuckles. Inside, through the thin wood, I could hear the muffled sound of my ten-month-old baby sobbing, his little gasps choked with fright. And beneath his cries, a sweet, high-pitched voice was singing: "Rock-a-bye baby, on the tree top..."
"Georgia, open this door!" David shouted, hurling his six-foot-two frame against the latch. The wood groaned, but the brass deadbolt—installed just three weeks ago—held fast. "I swear to God, Georgia, if you touch him, I will kill you!"
"He's wet, David," Georgia’s calm, sing-song voice came through the grain of the door. "You and Clara always leave him in wet clothes. Josh hates being wet. Mom told me you were neglectful. She gave me the key so I could fix your mistakes."
My breath hitched. Mom.
My mother hadn't just testified against us in court to protect her "fragile" daughter; she had tracked down our unlisted suburban address, copied the emergency master key we had stupidly left in her care months before the restraining order hearing, and handed it to a unstable woman who believed my biological child was her deceased son.
"Georgia, please," I sobbed, dropping to my knees, pressing my mouth against the gap between the door and the floor. "Please, Georgia. Look at his face. Look at his birthmark on his left thigh. That’s Sam. Josh died four years ago in Saint Jude's Hospital. You held him, Georgia. You buried him. Please don't do this to Sam!"
The lullaby stopped abruptly. Silence stretched for three horrifying seconds.
"Josh didn't die," Georgia whispered, her tone dropping into a icy, flat monotone that terrified me far more than her screaming ever could. "You stole him from the incubator while I was under anesthesia. Mom said you were jealous because Mark left you. But I'm his mother, Clara. The ribbon knows. The ribbon always knows."
A loud CRACK echoed as David backed up to the far wall of the corridor and delivered a flying side-kick directly to the door handle. The frame splintered. He kicked it again, and the door burst open, swinging inward and crashing against the wall.
The room was bathed in the faint blue light of the sea-turtle nightlight.
Georgia was standing by the open bay window. The freezing rain was blowing inside, soaking the white lace curtains and plastering her dark hair to her hollow cheeks. In her left hand, she held the creepy porcelain baby doll, its face cracked, wearing the plastic hospital bracelet from the day Sam was born—a bracelet I had hidden in my jewelry box upstairs.
In her right arm, wrapped tightly in a heavy woolen blanket, was Sam. He was red-faced, thrashing his little legs, reaching his tiny, star-shaped hands toward me.
"Mama!" Sam shrieked, his voice hoarse. "Mama!"
"I'm here, baby! Mommy's here!" I took a step forward, but Georgia swung her leg over the low window sill.
We were on the second floor. Outside was a steep, slippery slate roof that sloped twenty feet down into a stone patio.
"Don't come any closer!" Georgia screamed, her eyes wide, yellowed, and bloodshot. "If you take one more step, Clara, I'll jump! We'll go meet Josh's real spirit together!"
David froze, extending his arms to block me. "Georgia, look at me," David said, his voice forced into a low, steady tremor. "Look at me, Georgia. You don't want to hurt Josh, right? If you fall, Josh gets hurt."
Georgia hesitated, her bare foot trembling on the wet, rain-slicked slate outside the window. "Josh... Josh needs to go home."
"I am his home, Georgia," I wept, dropping my hands to my sides, stripping away every ounce of my pride, my anger, my sanity, offering her total submission if it would keep my boy alive. "You're right. You're right, Georgia. I was just the carrier. You win. Just hand him to me so he doesn't get cold in the rain. You can come inside. We can feed him together. Please."
Georgia looked down at Sam, then looked at me. A bizarre, terrifying warmth softened her pale face. "You admit it? You admit you were just carrying him for me?"
"Yes," I lied, the words tasting like ash and bile on my tongue. "Yes, Georgia. He's yours. He's Josh. Just give him to his mother."
She smiled—a wide, vacant smile that made my stomach turn. She swung her leg back inside the room. "I knew you'd see reason, Clara. Mom always said you were the sensible twin."
She extended her arms toward me. I lunged forward, not caring about anything else in the universe, and snatched Sam into my chest. The instant my fingers locked around his solid, warm little body, David tackled Georgia to the floor, pinning her arms behind her back as she began to shriek like a wild animal.
Sirens wailed in the distance, their red and blue lights already flashing through the wet pine trees lining our driveway.
I sank into the corner of the nursery, holding my screaming son, rocking him wildly, feeling his heartbeat against mine. But as the police officers burst up the stairs with drawn weapons, my eyes fell onto the floor where Georgia had dropped her raincoat.
May you like
Spilled from the deep inner pocket of her coat were three things: a pair of surgical shears, a bottle of industrial chloroform, and a forged birth certificate from the State of New York listing the mother as Georgia Vance and the father as David Vance.
She hadn't just come to take my baby. She had planned to take my husband, too.
