Chapter 5 - The Deposition

Three weeks later, we were sitting in a sterile conference room on the twenty-second floor of a downtown legal skyscraper. The room smelled of polished wood, stale coffee, and cold, impending reality.
Across the table sat my mother, my father, and Mark, crammed behind a lone defense attorney who looked visibly exhausted and deeply outmatched.
My mother was wearing a high-collared navy dress, looking frail and tearful, playing the part of the heartbroken mother to perfection. My father sat stiffly beside her, staring at the floor. Mark was shuffling through a stack of papers, sweating through his collar.
On our side of the table sat Sarah Vance, two junior associates, and me. I wore a tailored black blazer, my hair pulled back, my eyes fixed on my mother.
The court reporter clicked her machine into gear. "This is the deposition of Eleanor Vance in the matter of Natalie Vance v. Eleanor Vance, Arthur Vance, and Mark Vance."
Sarah leaned forward, placing her elbows on the table, her tone deceptively sweet. "Mrs. Vance, let's start with the events of July 14th at the restaurant. Did you or did you not tell your six-year-old adopted granddaughter, Lena, that the family toast was 'for real family only'?"
My mother dabbed her eye with a pristine white handkerchief. "I... I was misunderstood. I loved Lena from the moment I saw her. I merely felt that the toast was a historical tribute to our biological ancestors. I didn't want the poor child to be overwhelmed by complex family lineage."
"I see," Sarah said smoothly. "And was it out of concern for her complex understanding of lineage that you called Child Protective Services two weeks later?"
"I was worried!" my mother cried, her voice cracking with dramatic flair. "Natalie was acting so unhinged! She was cutting off family members! A mother knows when her child is having a mental breakdown, and I feared for that little girl’s safety!"
Sarah pulled a printed document from her binder and slid it across the table.
"Mrs. Vance, this is the official transcript of your call to the CPS hotline, obtained via court subpoena. On line 14, you stated, and I quote: 'My daughter bought this child from a corrupt agency to fill a void in her marriage, and she is keeping her in an unstable environment where the child is subjected to emotional abuse.' End quote."
My mother froze. Her handkerchief stopped midway to her face.
"Is that statement true, Mrs. Vance?" Sarah asked. "Did my client buy a child?"
"It... it was an expression of concern..." my mother stammered, her eyes darting to her lawyer.
"It is a sworn statement to a law enforcement agency," Sarah snapped, her voice suddenly dropping its polite veneer. "It is perjury. It is a false report. And it was made exactly forty-eight hours after my client revoked your free access to the luxury lake cabins."
"That has nothing to do with this!" my father interjected, slamming his hand on the table. "Natalie owes us respect! We raised her!"
"Mr. Vance, you will have your turn to speak," Sarah said coldly. She turned her attention to Mark. "Mr. Vance, let's discuss the blog post published on August 2nd."
Mark flinched. "I didn't write that."
Sarah slid another document across the table. "This is a digital forensics report detailing the IP address, device MAC address, and personal metadata attached to the submission. It originated from your home laptop at 11:14 PM on August 1st. Would you like to revise your answer under penalty of perjury?"
Mark’s attorney leaned over, whispered urgently into Mark’s ear, and then looked up at Sarah. "We'd like to request a five-minute recess."
"No recess," I spoke up for the first time, my voice ringing clear across the room.
May you like
Everyone looked at me. My mother stared at me with a mixture of rage and terror.
"There are no more recesses, Mom," I said quietly. "There are no more second chances. You are going to listen to me now."